There are plenty of places to eat Key Lime pie in Key West Florida. Whether you’re planning a short trip or a vacation, you’ll have no trouble finding a place to satisfy your sweet tooth. Here are a few popular spots.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe
It’s hard to beat a classic Key lime pie. Thankfully, Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe is able to deliver the best of the best to your door. They boast a wide variety of tasty Key lime treats including key lime tarts, chocolate covered key limes and even a Key Lime Pie bar dipped in dark chocolate.
The Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Pie Shoppe is located in the heart of historic Key West Bight. It’s a short stroll from Mallory Square and Mallory Park. With a full menu and outdoor seating, you’ll never have to go far to enjoy a traditional pie. You can also pick up single slices or complete pies in a range of flavors.
Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Restaurant is a staple in the quaint seaside town. Having been opened more than twenty years, it’s still going strong. Guests can indulge in a variety of Key lime creations, from the best key lime pie you’ll ever taste to an impressive array of bath and body goodies.
Salute! on the Beach
If you’re looking for a restaurant in Key West, look no further than Salute! With an idyllic beachside setting and delicious cuisine, it’s no wonder this place is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.
This is an Italian-themed eatery with Caribbean flair. The menu features fresh seafood and Caribbean-influenced dishes. It’s the perfect spot to enjoy an ocean view meal with a friend or partner. Whether you’re visiting on a sunny weekend or on a romantic retreat, it’s easy to fall in love with the laid-back vibe of this cafe.
Key Lime Pie, one of the signature items at Salute, is a must-try. A traditional key lime pie is prepared with a graham cracker crust and creamy key lime custard. To top it off, it’s topped with a mound of fluffy meringue.
Old Town Bakery
Key lime pie is a Florida staple and a dessert that’s impossible to resist. Whether you’re looking for an authentic Florida key lime pie or want to try a more sophisticated version, you’ll be spoiled for choice in the Keys.
Old Town Bakery is a family-owned business that opened in 2010. The store features a cozy vibe and a wide selection of baked goods. There’s a variety of cakes, breads, croissants, and even gluten-free chocolate-dipped bars. You can also find sandwiches, cheese, and cold drinks.
This establishment is a perfect place to visit for a picnic or to indulge in an ice cream cone. It has a beachside cafe atmosphere. Besides serving its famous key lime pie, it serves a number of other enticing treats.
Old Town Bakery is a small, family-run business that has been in business since May 2010. As a result, they’ve repurposed the building’s 19th-century charm. Inside, there’s a glass-front pastry display case and some old wooden beams.
Mattheessen’s Key Lime Pie is one of the most famous Key West desserts. It’s made with fresh lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and a graham cracker crust. In addition to the traditional key lime pie, they also have a variety of other key lime treats, like key lime macaroons, key lime pecans, and Key West’s favorite, chocolate on a stick.
While this isn’t the only key lime pie you can find in Key West, the Mattheessen family has been producing quality products in their family owned business for over 40 years. They opened their first store in 1994, and now have two more locations on Duval Street. You can also get your hands on Mattheessen’s homemade fudge, marble slab fudge, and key lime cookies.
For a more exotic treat, try a ‘dip in dark Belgian chocolate’ from Mattheessen’s. Or if you prefer something sweeter, try their toasted coconut key lime pie.
Home of the first Key Lime pie
Key Lime pie is one of the most popular desserts in the state of Florida. The Key lime was first introduced in the late 1800s and is considered an official Florida pie. There are countless variations of the recipe. It typically has a graham cracker crust with a filling that is citrusy. Many top the pie with whipped cream, but a meringue topping is also common.
Key lime pie is a staple in the Florida Keys and was made famous by a woman named Aunt Sally. She perfected the recipe for a wealthy man in the Keys in the late 1800s.
Key limes are small, yellow, and have a thin skin. They are not usually available in the produce sections. Despite this, they are prized for their unique flavor.